Positive pop song that's so darn catchyReviewed by myabsurdlife.com, 2010-01-04
I can't help myself. My Broadway tunes have been temporarily
abandoned for "The Climb." I was never a Britney, Jessica or
Christina fan, so I never imagined myself loving a song by Miley
Cyrus, a Disney-produced pop star.
What I really like is how the song starts off with just the piano
and her voice. Then the strings come in. Then guitars. And finally
the drums come in to beat home the message. Sure, the music repeats
itself and gets embedded in your brain, as one would expect. But
it's not in a bad way like having the word "Disturbia" or
"Paparazzi" stuck in your head all day. Though trite, being
reminded to "keep the faith" and keep reaching for your dreams
still leaves a minty-fresh feeling in your soul.
As for the voice, it works for this song. Kelly Clarkson or
Jennifer Hudson could have turned "The Climb" into a powerful
piece, but with Miley at the helm, the song seems more accessible,
i.e., easier for the average person to sing along with, not
impossibly Mariah Carey-ish. This makes the song stick even
more.
So, yes, I love a song with the words, "whoa-oh," "baby" and
"yeah-ah," something I never thought would happen. What does this
mean? Maybe there really is something about Miley because "Party in
the U.S.A." is starting to grow on me, too.
One Word: OverproducedReviewed by Kody Boye, 2009-09-09
I can appreciate talent, and I can appreciate young singers with
vocal talent whose voices have not yet fully matured. What I cannot
respect under any circumstance is overproduction in the vocal
department.
Miley Cyrus' 'The Climb' has been one of the greatest,
chart-topping songs this year alone. With previous songs such as
'Seven Things' and 'Fly on the Wall,' it was surprising to hear an
inspirational piece on such a scope come from Miley, whom I never
expected to attempt such a theme. But, despite the lyrics, and
despite how well done the song might by done musically, it fails
vocally, if only because it is overproduced. Compared to the
studio, the live version is filled with so much nasal singing that
it makes it almost unbearable to listen to.
Miley Cyrus, while an ambitious young woman, is no one to be
admired musically. There are many more talented singers out there
that deserve to have a record deal comparable to Cyrus'. Sadly,
though, many of them will never get that chance because they don't
fit the mold the music industry is trying to fill with
vocally-untalented Disney Stars who will appeal to teens and
preteens.
'The Climb' is beautiful--lyrically, not vocally.
WOWReviewed by Kenneth W. Kaletta, 2009-08-28
I don't write reviews. Mainly because the other reviews are to the point. One of the reviewers said that they got chills when they listened to this song. I know exactly what they mean. This song makes you look deep at yourself and lets you look forward to your own "clime"!
Packaged For The PublicReviewed by Jenny Smyth, 2009-08-18
Mylee Cyrus is just another example of big corporations packaging teens for the public consumption. This song "The Climb" is just a poorer version of artist Cindy Black's "3 Second Ride" which came out almost ten years ago. Mylee seems to struggle with carrying a tune and her performances are weak. The message of the song is inspirational but has been done before.
Love it!Reviewed by Robyn 808, 2009-07-31
I know its Hannah Montana but this sound has a lot of great advise
and meaning for me.
Love it!!!